Ok - now I think I understand.
I think you should research the DLookup function.
When you enter your MemberID and click your button on the popup - you should have VBA code in the Click Event of the button that says something like this:
Code:
Dim MemID as Long 'Assuming your MemberID is a number . . .
MemID = Me.txtMemberID.Value
If DLookup("FieldName", "TableName", "MemberID = " & Nz(MemID,0)) = 0 Then
' FieldName is 0 because the MemberID doesn't exist.
DoCmd.OpenForm "Form2"
Else
' FieldName is not 0 because the MemberID does exist.
DoCmd.OpenForm "Form1"
End If
I haven't tested this code but put it up to give you a start.
Let me know if you have problems with it.